Nick Woltemade shares who he thinks was better between Alan Shearer and Wayne Rooney

Written on Friday, 05 December 2025
Jonathan Gorrie

Nick Woltemade is not making missteps at Newcastle United, either on or off the pitch. 

Woltemade’s start to life at Newcastle United has been little short of stunning, even if the team around him are yet to fully convince. 

The German international has already scored seven goals this season and looks capable of being the club’s next iconic striker.

Does Newcastle United’s recruitment structure need a revamp? The focus on Premier League experience is WILD

Jacob Ramsey, Anthony Elanga and Aaron Ramsdale have all struggled this season…. 😟

Photo by Ryan Crockett/DeFodi Images/DeFodi via Getty Images
👇Join the debate; share your insight. Use the comment button on the bottom left to have your say

Clearly, there’s a long way to go on that front but the 23-year-old has surely made greater strides than almost anyone would have expected.

Though he’s not yet in their company, Newcastle are a club famous for having excellent strikers

Alan Shearer is no doubt the standout even among that pantheon of greats and Woltemade appears to agree. 

Manchester City v Real Madrid C.F. - UEFA Champions League 2024/25 League Knockout Play-off First Leg
Photo by James Gill – Danehouse/Getty Images

Nick Woltemade says Alan Shearer was better than Wayne Rooney

Shearer, of course, is the Premier League’s record goalscorer.  

However, as time goes on, players of Woltemade’s generation and below may simply not have watched him at his brilliant best.

Shearer retired almost two decades ago now. Woltemade would have been a toddler at the time.  

Wayne Rooney was perhaps the Premier League’s standout forward during the late 2000s and early 2010s and may have been more visible to players of a younger vintage.  

Still, when asked who was the better player by Stern’s Tik Tok channel, Woltemade went for Shearer, which will surely delight a fanbase who already love him.  

If you bumped into Eddie Howe on the street right now, what changes would you tell him to make vs Burnley?!

I’d be telling him to get Anthony Gordon in the XI after his cameo against Spurs!

Eddie Howe looks on prior to Newcastle United's Champions League game against Marseille.
Photo by Alexander Hassenstein/Getty Images
👇Join the debate; share your insight. Use the comment button on the bottom left to have your say

The stats that prove Alan Shearer was a better striker than Wayne Rooney

Rooney was an absolutely brilliant player, so it’s certainly not a slight on him. A forward who scored 208 Premier League goals in 491 games deserves a huge amount of respect. 

However, the statistics even away from the goals paint Shearer in a much better light.

Premier League statisticsAlan ShearerWayne Rooney
Games441491
Goals260208
Assists64103
Minutes per goal146.9182.8
Hat-tricks117
Game-winning goals6866
Alan Shearer’s Premier League record compared to Wayne Rooney’s

Shearer boasted a better minutes per goal ratio, scored more hat-tricks and more game-winning goals.

Amazingly, Rooney almost joined Newcastle to play alongside Shearer in 2004.

There’s certainly an argument to suggest Rooney had more to his game than purely goals, although that was also true of Shearer before a series of knee injuries.

Woltemade isn’t just toeing the party line here…