Report: Italian media are at it again as strange Sandro Tonali Newcastle exit claim made

Written on Wednesday, 24 December 2025
Jonathan Gorrie

Sandro Tonali’s name has again emerged in the Italian media as they dream of a return from Newcastle United. 

After a sticky start to his career at Newcastle United, midfielder Tonali has emerged into one of the best in his position in European football. 

Along with Tino Livramento, Tonali is surely Newcastle’s most prized asset following the summer departure of Alexander Isak.

Knowing what you know now, would you have sold Alexander Isak in 2024 instead of Elliot Anderson? 🤔

In this scenario, we still win the Carabao Cup by the way 😂

One didn’t want to leave. The other did his best to.

Photo by Molly Darlington/Getty Images
👇Join the debate; share your insight. Use the comment button on the bottom left to have your say

However, Tonali has frequently been linked with a move to Juventus. The Italian media appear to love the idea of him returning to Serie A.  

Now, more strange claims have emerged.

Italian media say Juventus could look to sign Sandro Tonali on loan

Indeed, Gazzetta dello Sport suggest that playing for Juventus would appeal to Tonali.

The 25-year-old is famously an AC Milan fan but they claim the Old Lady do have a place in the player’s heart.

The report goes on to claim that Newcastle will only sell Tonali if he explicitly requests a move before a significant offer is made.

Even then, Juve may not be able to afford the deal. It’s said that they could even attempt an audacious loan move, including an obligation to buy.

Finally, they claim that striker Jonathan David could even be offered in part-exchange.

You’re offered £150m for Sandro Tonali in January, do you accept or reject? 💰

Easy answer for us! ❌

👇Join the debate; share your insight. Use the comment button on the bottom left to have your say

Sandro Tonali could leave Newcastle United next summer – but it won’t be on loan

Tonali’s long-term future at Newcastle is in doubt after he claimed earlier this season that no one can predict the future.  

Frankly, that is refreshingly honest. If Newcastle don’t finish in the Champions League spots this season, he could hardly be blamed for wanting to leave.

To be up front about not knowing what the future can hold is much better than what Isak did earlier this summer.

Sandro Tonali walks off the pitch after Newcastle United vs Chelsea.
Photo by Serena Taylor/Newcastle United via Getty Images

Either way, Newcastle are in a strong position over Tonali. He is effectively under contract until 2030 and it’s impossible to imagine they’d ever agree to a loan deal, even if there is an obligation to buy.

If Newcastle are going to sell Tonali, it’s going to be on their own terms.

Sign up to TalkingPoints for free to join the conversation about all things Newcastle United with Geordie Boot Boys!