Player Ratings Out Of Ten | Newcastle United Defenders | AWSF

The boys from All With Smiling Faces Podcast are back to put Newcastle United’s defenders under the microscope! From standout performers to disappointing campaigns, we’re rating every Newcastle defender from the 2025/26 season out of 10 and debating who impressed, who struggled, and who deserves another chance next season. Expect plenty of disagreements, strong opinions, and some controversial ratings as we break down the performances of Newcastle’s back line. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices